November 4th, 2026
Greetings!
Nearly two years ago, we were arguing at the New York Post why ‘World War III’ was President Donald Trump’s to win.
No, we did not advocate the overt use of American military force. Rather, we argued that Russian President Vladimir Putin and his so-called ‘special military operation’ in Ukraine was down for the count and that defeating Russia could win World War III for the West by ensuring Ukraine’s victory.
AI Image credit: Grok. Graphic depicting a gathering global storm.
We were hopeful that former President Biden’s escalation paralysis in Ukraine – especially as it was overseen by former national security adviser Jake Sullivan – was on the way out. Instead, as time would prove, Trump focused on de-escalating the war and in the process allowed Putin time and space to continue attacking Ukraine.
There were solid reasons why we believed the U.S. was on the cusp of a great victory. Others, including retired U.S. Army Gen. Jack Keane, were seeing what we were assessing: that Trump, upon retaking office, would be faced with a “major strategic shift” in that the Axis of Evil as led by Russia and China were at war with the West.
Plus, Trump had appointed retired U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg as his chief special envoy to Russia and Ukraine. In our Thursday column at The Hill, we argued that Kellogg was just the right man to deal with Putin.
Trump – and by extension Kellogg – held all of the cards then. Russia, by early December 2024, had incurred 747,340 casualties in Ukraine. The Baltic Sea had become a NATO lake after the accession of Sweden and Finland to the now 32-member pact. Russia’s Black Sea Fleet was forced to flee Crimea – and the Russian navy was being forced to abandon its Mediterranean seaport of Tartus as the Assad regime collapsed.
By that point in time, for 34 months running, Putin had been able to play the nuclear bluff game against the Biden Administration. We warned about it again and again – and pointed out Putin used Russia’s nuclear arsenal as a Russian-style Teddy Bear to mollify its citizens every time things went south in Ukraine.
Kellogg – arguably uniquely so given his U.S. Army 82nd Airborne background – was well-positioned to finally call that bluff and tell Putin to his face what was already clear to us by December 2022: Russia was losing the war in Ukraine and that it had no conventional path to victory.
Except there was a problem. Putin did not want to meet with Kellogg – and Trump caved in to his demand to effectively demote the hard-as-nails general to being just the special White House envoy to Ukraine.
Kellogg was out and Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner were in – and ever since, thousands more Ukrainian soldiers and civilians have died because Trump appeased Putin and turned to two ill-equipped commercial developers.
Russians have paid the price as well. Despite Trump’s repeated boasts that he could end the Russia-Ukraine war in “24 hours,” the conflict has dragged on another two years, and Putin’s army has accumulated another 849,670 casualties.
And it is only getting worse. For the fourth month in a row, Russia has suffered 40,000 or more casualties in Ukraine. In October alone, Putin’s military forces lost 54,400 dead or wounded soldiers.
That is 1,597,010 Russian casualties alone since February 24th, 2022. Putin, of course, does not care. Unless he is stopped, he is not going to stop trying to conquer all of Ukraine and achieve his Black Sea land bridge stemming from Russia to Crimea to Odesa to Transnistria to Moldova and likely beyond.
Kellogg’s ouster was a harbinger of things to come. Much like during his first term, Trump has come to not trust his military advisers.
Instead of taking their counsel, far too often he relies on his own business instincts, and as a result, especially with respect to the wars in Ukraine and in Iran, it has caused conflicts to go sideways and devolve into the very ‘forever wars’ that he was adamant about putting an end to during his campaign for a second term.
Putin figured that out early on. After prompting Trump to dump Kellogg, the Russian dictator appointed Kirill Dmitriev, the head of the Russian Direct Investment Fund – which is often referred to as Putin’s ‘slush fund’ – as his chief envoy to the U.S.
Dmitriev’s task was at worst to cause Trump’s efforts to end the war to go sideways or at best to buy from Trump what Russia’s military has been incapable of winning on the battlefield: Ukraine’s surrender or capitulation in the Donbas.
Given Trump’s obsession with making “deals,” the latter became Dmitriev’s primary course of action. In pursuit of that goal, he has dangled upwards of $14 trillion of business deals designed to get Trump to sell out Ukraine.
Witkoff and Kushner bit hard and have been trying ever since to convince Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky to commit – militarily speaking – national suicide by ceding Ukraine’s strategic Fortress Belt in the Donbas that has held back the Russian horde from Odesa, Kyiv and the rest of Ukraine.
That, as we have said many times, is not going to happen. The Ukrainians as a people have not fought this hard and sacrificed this much blood and treasure to win a war only to stop and allow Trump – with Witkoff and Kushner acting as his agents – to lose it for them. The ghosts of the dead will not let them.
Plus, Dmitriev’s deals are, as we argued three weeks ago in The Hill, simply fool’s gold designed to play Team Trump for fools. It is also why we argued a week later in The Hill that Trump had to stop trying to deliver Ukraine to Putin.
Iran – as we will argue tomorrow in The Hill – quickly learned this same lesson albeit with a twist. They played to Trump’s dealmaking ego and in doing so turned the forever ceasefire we warned about at USA Today into what they perceive as an electoral defeat of the president in yesterday’s drubbing of Republicans at the polls.
Iran is right about one thing. The U.S. election was – and still is – an inflection point in terms of who ultimately wins World War III.
Tehran’s nuclear weapons program is not going to go away. If Trump cuts and runs, Iran after being attacked, will sprint to building nukes.
If Trump simply continues business as usual – meaning waiting for U.S. economic sanctions or airstrikes to work – then this forever ceasefire will at some point morph into a costly forever war draining U.S. money and military assets.
It truly is a catch-22 situation. Trump cannot achieve his frequently stated objective of ensuring Iran does not get nukes unless he effects top-to-bottom regime change in Iran. Nothing less will work.
However, neither side of the aisle on Capitol Hill – especially due to Trump’s decision not to prosecute the war to a decisive end when victory was in his grasp in March – is anywhere close to pursuing regime change.
Nor are the American people as a whole supportive of doing so given yesterday’s midterm results. They are understandably focused on affordability and salaries that keep up or exceed the rate of inflation. Simply put, Trump has woefully failed to adequately explain what is at stake and what the consequences of doing nothing are.
Likewise – and again a respectful reminder that we are apolitical in our national security analyses and are decidedly not political experts – we fully understand that U.S. national security and foreign policy decisions, especially the war in Iran, are likely to become highly politicized by all sides for partisan gain.
We witnessed that today when Vice President JD Vance – in an obvious bid to win over isolationists like Tucker Carlson with an eye on 2028 – blamed Republican losses on the war in Iran. Equally, we also saw the efforts of some Washington-based isolationist media, including The Federalist, take aim at anyone advocating for ensuring Iran does not get a nuke by labeling them neocons.
Our goal here is not to delve into the politics of it all. We happily will leave that to others. Our only goal is to sift through the fog of partisan politics to make sure all Americans are aware of the very real national security threats facing the U.S.
We cannot wish away Iran’s very real nuclear weapons program. Nor can we ignore it, especially since it represents an existential risk to the U.S.
Nor can we dictate a solution. That said, we hope that we can facilitate a forum to decide how, on a bipartisan basis, the Iranian threat to the U.S. can either be contained or eliminated altogether by forcing regime change.
The U.S. did not want to face the threats Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany represented in the 1930s – and that led to Pearl Harbor. We cannot and must not make that same mistake in 2026 given Iran’s nuclear state of play.
Bipartisanship is key to making sure that does not happen. So too does the outcome of World War III, which – while it does not look like Hollywood’s version of mushroom clouds and nightmare day-after scenarios – is still being waged against the West by Russia and China and their Axis of Evil allies.
The U.S. and its allies can still win it. Doing so begins by winning in Ukraine and putting an end to a very evil and repressive regime in Iran – or we can ignore the gathering storm and eventually pay a bloody price for doing so.
***
PROGRAMMING NOTE
Tomorrow in our weekly Thursday 7 AM ET national security column in The Hill in Washington, D.C., we argue that Iran outplayed Trump and as a result won big in the U.S. midterms. It really was in soccer terms an own goal.
Find out why here when it goes live.
***
ICYMI #1
Jon appeared on Q News today in Cairo, Egypt. It is the English-speaking service of Al Qahera News TV.
You can watch a clip here. The program is in English.
***
ICYMI #2
Mark appeared today on Al Qahera TV News. He was joined by Victoria Churchill, a former fellow writer at the New York Post who now writes for the Daily Mail covering politics for the London-based paper in Washington, D.C.
You can watch a clip here or you can watch the entire program here.
***
Thank you for reading. We will see you tomorrow. Please subscribe, comment & share. We truly appreciate it.
Jon & Mark
Follow Jon on X at @JESweet2022 or on Bluesky at @JonSweet.bsky.social. Follow Mark on X at @MCTothSTL or on Bluesky at @MarkToth.bsky.social.







No matter what the US does, Israel will never allow Iran to possess nuclear weapons. As with Ukraine, which will never give up the Donbas, these are existential, non-negotiable and ethically fully defensible issues.